In Alaska’s authorized confusion over public funds for personal education, Regulation Division says it is below evaluate

In Alaska’s authorized confusion over public funds for personal education, Regulation Division says it is below evaluate

In Alaska’s authorized confusion over public funds for personal education, Regulation Division says it is below evaluate
The Brady Constructing in downtown Anchorage is the placement of the Alaska legal professional normal’s workplace, on June 3, 2022, in Anchorage, Alaska. (Photograph by Andrew Kitchenman/Alaska Beacon)

The state Division of Regulation is reviewing whether or not it’s authorized for Alaska households to make use of public schooling funds they obtain within the type of homeschooling allotments to pay for personal college.

That’s based on reporting by the Alaska Beacon, which discovered that some correspondence colleges have already been reimbursing households for personal college courses below a regulation enacted in 2014.

However, because the Beacon additionally factors out, the Alaska Structure says the state can’t pay public funds to any non secular or in any other case personal academic establishment.

So there may be, on the very least, some confusion. And because the Regulation Division appears into the problem, the Legal professional Normal has recused himself as a result of his spouse is an outspoken proponent of the observe.

Alaska Beacon reporter Lisa Phu has been following this, and she or he says her reporting began with what she thought can be a easy query.


[Sign up for Alaska Public Media’s daily newsletter to get our top stories delivered to your inbox.]

The next transcript has been frivolously edited for readability.

Lisa Phu: So I began trying into this one query: Can households enrolled in a state funded correspondence program use their allotment to pay for personal college courses? Is that authorized? I figured the Division of Training and Early Improvement would be capable to reply it. However they couldn’t. A spokesperson mentioned the query was at the moment being reviewed by the Division of Regulation. And due to that, nobody on the Division of Training might converse to it. So then I reached out to the Division of Regulation. I requested the identical query, “Is that this authorized?” And I obtained the identical reply. I used to be instructed it was below evaluate, so nobody might converse to it. Proper now in our state, there are households with college students enrolled in state-funded correspondence packages, or homeschools, who’re utilizing their allotment to pay for personal college courses. So households are paying upfront for personal college after which asking for a correspondence program for reimbursement.

Casey Grove: And I suppose we use “correspondence college” and “homeschooling” form of interchangeably right here, proper? However are you able to clarify extra about how correspondence colleges work in Alaska? What does this allotment program appear to be?

LP: Certain, yeah, you’re proper, Casey. So in Alaska, correspondence college and homeschool are just about synonymous and are used interchangeably. College districts in Alaska can set up state-funded correspondence colleges for households who select to homeschool their youngsters. They’re below the varsity district, in order that they’re public packages. Alaska has about 34 correspondence college packages. And right here’s how the funding works: Correspondence or homeschool college students are funded at 90{580e7ab747ba2a04fc173e40bbefe4ede9863ae746bdb3e85bcb603e1a2cbd5a} of the bottom quantity the state pays per pupil. That’s also called the BSA. Presently, the BSA is $5,930. So 90{580e7ab747ba2a04fc173e40bbefe4ede9863ae746bdb3e85bcb603e1a2cbd5a} of that. A correspondence college can move that alongside to households by way of an allotment program. How a lot is handed alongside is completely different relying on the homeschool program. I talked to 1 program that may provide $3,000 for prime schoolers and $2,600 for (kindergarten) by way of eighth grade beginning this fall. I talked to a different program that gives $4,000 per pupil. So this allotment, regardless of the quantity, can be utilized on the educational-related wants of the coed, like books, courses, college provides, expertise help, tutoring, music or different actions.

CG: Lisa, you mentioned there are college students enrolled in state-funded homeschool packages who’re utilizing their allotment to pay for personal college courses? How widespread is that this observe?

LP: So I don’t know the scope of it. In my reporting to date, I do know Mat-Su Central, which is a homeschool program, a part of the Mat-Su Borough College District, has been doing it for 3 years. And Household Partnership Constitution College in Anchorage plans to begin permitting it within the fall. Because the story ran, I’ve heard and examine different correspondence packages providing it.

CG: Gotcha. And that needs to be secular, as in not non secular, proper? Why is that?

LP: There’s a state statute that the correspondence colleges level to, which they are saying permits this observe. The statute says a household might buy nonsectarian or nonreligious providers and supplies from a public, personal or non secular group with the coed allotment. So the principals I talked to essentially emphasize the nonreligious requirement and say they’ve a vetting course of to find out what personal college programs are eligible for reimbursement. That statute language was initially a part of Senate Invoice 100, which then-Senator Mike Dunleavy — who’s now the governor, after all — sponsored in 2014. The invoice went by way of a number of committee hearings, however the language finally handed that 12 months as a part of Home Invoice 278. In order that’s the statute. However the Alaska Structure has one thing to say on the problem as properly. That’s Article VII, Part 1 of the Alaska Structure. It says, “No cash shall be paid from public funds for the direct advantage of any non secular or different personal academic establishment.” So there seems to be confusion and additional want for authorized evaluation. And the Division of Training isn’t including any readability to the confusion till it hears from the Division of Regulation.

CG: That authorized evaluation, or evaluate, by the Regulation Division appears to be posing one other concern, and that’s a possible battle of curiosity, proper? Clarify that to me.

LP: Yeah, I did one other story about that. Alaska’s Legal professional Normal Treg Taylor is married to Jodi Taylor, who’s board president of the Alaska Coverage Discussion board. She is a serious proponent of utilizing public funds for personal college schooling. And final month, she wrote publicly about her plan to hunt as much as $8,000 in reimbursements for his or her two children attending an Anchorage personal college. And, you realize, on this Op Ed she additionally presents directions for a way households can use state-funded correspondence college allotments for courses at personal colleges. So Jodi Taylor is married to Alaska Legal professional Normal Treg Taylor, so there was a priority that as a result of his household might financially profit, that he might have a battle. Seems, the Regulation Division thought the identical factor. So after his spouse’s Op Ed was revealed on a number of web sites and blogs, the Legal professional Normal recused himself from all issues involving correspondence college allotments, after which he delegated the evaluate to Deputy Legal professional Normal Cori Mills.

CG: Do now we have any thought when this evaluate can be accomplished?

LP: Mills wasn’t in a position to give any extra particulars of the evaluate or a timeline of when an opinion might come out. She did say at any time when an opinion is prepared, it could be as much as the Division of Training to offer any clarification to high school districts.

[Sign up for Alaska Public Media’s daily newsletter to get our top stories delivered to your inbox.]